Main Content

Bexley

Bexley
Bexley, Ohio

MEDIAN HOME PRICES
LowestMedianHighest
$499,830$789,900$1,135,670
MEDIAN HOME PRICE PER SQUARE FEET
LowestMedianHighest
$266$283$290
AVERAGE HOME STATISTICS IN TERMS OF:
No. of bedsNo. of bathsSquare feet
322,111

Source: Realtor.com (May 2024)


Nestled in the heart of Franklin County, Bexley is a city and a first-ring suburb of Columbus known for its exceptional quality of life.


Founded as a village in 1908 and later incorporated as a city in 1928, Bexley offers a unique blend of historic charm and modern convenience. This close-knit community boasts a highly rated public school system, making it a superb choice for families. Stroll down the walkable Main Street, brimming with shops and cafes, or explore the beautiful parks. Bexley’s proximity to Columbus provides access to big-city amenities while maintaining its small-town feel. Whether you’re seeking rich history, a vibrant cultural scene, or a safe and welcoming environment, Bexley has something for everyone.


Interested in Bexley, Ohio homes for sale? Here, we shine the spotlight on this community. We’ll give you a closer look at the lifestyle, the real estate options, the best attractions and destinations, and all of the things that make Bexley an outstanding place to call home.


OVERVIEW OF BEXLEY, OHIO


Bexley’s history at a glance


  • The city’s name has a transatlantic connection – it was named Bexley at the suggestion of an early resident, Col. Lincoln Kilbourne, paying homage to his family roots in Bexley, a district in London, England.

  • Bexley’s origins can be traced back to 1908 when two distinct neighborhoods, the prestigious Bullitt Park and the Lutheran college community of Pleasant Ridge, decided to unite and incorporate as the Village of Bexley.

  • Bullitt Park, founded in 1889 by Logan M. Bullitt of Philadelphia, quickly attracted wealthy residents of Columbus who built elegant urban townhouses and sprawling country homes along Broad Street and Town Road (now Bryden Road), extending all the way to Franklin Park.

  • A pivotal moment in Bexley’s history occurred in 1898 when Ohio Governor Asa Bushnell designated a cluster of unsold lots in Bullitt Park as Camp Bushnell, an assembly site for 8,000 Ohio volunteers headed for the Spanish-American War in Cuba.

  • Bexley reached the 5,000 population mark required to become a city in 1928. In 1932, it officially transitioned from a village to a city, with William A. Schneider elected as its first mayor.

  • In a testament to its commitment to preserving its natural heritage, Bexley achieved a unique distinction in 2013 when it became the first city in the United States to be accredited as an arboretum by the Morton Register of Arboreta.

Location


Bexley is located east of downtown Columbus, encompassing approximately 2.5 square miles along the banks of Alum Creek, adjacent to Driving Park and Wolfe Park, and east of the Franklin Park Conservatory. The city’s origins stem from the merger of two distinct neighborhoods – the upscale Bullitt Park to the north and the Lutheran college community of Pleasant Ridge to the south.


Climate


Bexley, Ohio, experiences a temperate climate characterized by warm summers and cold winters. The average summer temperature hovers around 75°F, while winter months bring an average of around 35°F. Precipitation is a consistent presence throughout the year, though it tends to be more frequent during the spring and fall seasons. Snowfall occurs occasionally in the winter, typically amounting to a few inches at a time.


Despite its inland location, Bexley maintains relatively low humidity levels across all seasons. The city receives an average of 40 inches of rainfall annually, slightly above the national average, while its yearly snowfall of 23 inches falls slightly below the US average. Residents can expect to enjoy around 175 sunny days per year in Bexley.


Economy


Bexley boasts a robust local economy bolstered by its proximity to the thriving city of Columbus. Its stable and prosperous business landscape, comprising a diverse range of industries, provides ample employment opportunities and economic security for residents.


With educational services, healthcare, social assistance, and retail trade emerging as leading sectors, the city’s job market caters to a wide array of professions. The construction, finance, and insurance industries rank among the highest-paying sectors, further contributing to Bexley’s economic vitality. Additionally, the city benefits from its central location, with major regional employers like JPMorgan Chase and Nationwide.


Education


With a higher concentration of students per capita than any other city in central Ohio, Bexley is home to a diverse array of prestigious educational institutions catering to learners of all ages.


The Bexley City School District is renowned as one of the top public school systems in the state. The district’s guiding mission and strategic priorities, shaped by community stakeholders, ensure a well-rounded educational experience complemented by a rich array of courses and extracurricular programs.


Bexley’s educational landscape also boasts two prestigious private K-12 institutions. The Columbus School for Girls (CSG), established in 1898, has instilled strength and grace in young women, empowering them to discover their distinct potential. St. Charles Preparatory Academy, founded in 1923, has challenged young men to embrace a tradition of excellence, fostering their growth as well-rounded individuals prepared for advanced study.


Bexley also has two highly rated private higher education institutions. Capital University, a private four-year undergraduate and graduate school, offers an immersive, high-impact educational experience tailored to refining each student’s unique purpose. Trinity Lutheran Seminary, steeped in faith-based training, equips students for transformative ministry across various settings, from congregational leadership to social justice advocacy.


BEXLEY, OHIO HOMES FOR SALE


Couple Inside Home

Those looking for Bexley, Ohio homes for sale can choose from a wide variety of residences catering to nearly any type of preference or requirement. Bexley’s real estate market primarily consists of single-family homes mixed with upscale condo and townhome developments. There’s a terrific selection of new construction homes as well as many renowned local architects like Lauerhass Architecture and Pete Foster Residential Design for those who want to craft their dream custom home.


Single-family homes in Bexley are available in elegant architectural styles such as Cape Cod, Georgian, Victorian, Tudor Revival, and Colonial Revival. Many homes offer a seamless blend of comfort, privacy, and livability, while also showcasing the city’s rich historical heritage through their timeless designs and meticulous preservation.


For those seeking luxurious living in Bexley, there’s a diverse selection of high-end homes guaranteed to impress even the most discerning homebuyer. Many luxury homes in Bexley are equipped with a range of first-rate features such as grand entryways with curved staircases, gourmet kitchens with top-of-the-line appliances, luxurious master suites with spa-like bathrooms, home theaters or entertainment rooms, finished basements, and beautifully landscaped grounds with amenities like pools, cabanas, or outdoor kitchens.


Ready to browse the finest selection of Bexley, Ohio homes for sale? Take a look at our Featured Properties!


Neighborhoods in Bexley


Bexley is home to several neighborhoods offering a unique blend of historic charm and modern amenities. From tree-lined streets with stately homes to vibrant areas with trendy shops and restaurants, Bexley’s diverse neighborhoods cater to a variety of lifestyles and preferences.


Here’s a quick look at some of the top-rated neighborhoods in the area:


  • Bexley Park. Located in the western part of Bexley, Bexley Park is known for its scenic tree-lined streets and charming single-family homes. The neighborhood offers a peaceful, family-friendly atmosphere with well-maintained parks and recreational facilities, making it an attractive choice for those seeking a laid-back lifestyle.

  • Bexley Highlands. Situated on the east side of Bexley, this area offers a mix of architectural styles and a variety of housing options. Bexley Highlands features both historic properties and new construction, providing residents with a diverse range of homes to suit different preferences and budgets.

  • Bexley Plaza. Bexley Plaza offers a dream lifestyle with its stylish and spacious 1, 2, and 3-bedroom apartments and townhomes. This attractive, pet-friendly, and affordable complex provides all the desired features and amenities, including in-unit washer/dryer connections, ample closet space, and easy online rent payments via a resident portal. Residents can enjoy the best of city living while coming home to a comfortable, well-maintained community.

  • Lyonsgate. One of the most coveted neighborhoods in Bexley, Lyonsgate is an exclusive gated community featuring a collection of elegant single-family homes, perfect for those who value peace of mind and a friendly atmosphere.

LIVING IN BEXLEY, OHIO


Parks and outdoor destinations


Gazebo and Lily Pond

Bexley residents are always minutes away from parks and outdoor destinations offering a wide range of recreational opportunities for all ages. Be sure to check out some of these venues in and around the Bexley area:


Franklin Conservatory and Botanical Gardens
1777 E. Broad Street Columbus, OH 43203


Franklin Park Conservatory and Botanical Gardens is a horticultural oasis in Columbus, offering a captivating journey through exotic plant collections and compelling art exhibits. This botanical landmark features biomes representing global climate zones, showcasing diverse flora from the Himalayan Mountains to tropical rainforests.


Visitors can explore themed gardens, witness seasonal displays, and marvel at the stunning Dale Chihuly artworks. Set within the 88-acre Franklin Park, the conservatory provides educational programming, special events, and a tranquil escape, elevating the quality of life for all ages through its natural surroundings and cultural experiences.


Jeffrey Park

Escape the city bustle and explore the natural beauty of Jeffrey Park. Spanning 40 acres, this Bexley gem offers over a mile of trails winding through diverse ecosystems. Hike beneath towering sycamores, spot vibrant wildflowers, or listen for the calls of owls and hawks. Amenities abound, from a refreshing community pool and tennis courts to playgrounds and a historic mansion. Jeffrey Park is a haven for nature lovers, families, and anyone seeking a peaceful escape, all within Bexley’s borders.


Schneider Park

Nestled in Bexley’s southwest corner, Schneider Park offers a delightful outdoor retreat with diverse amenities. It features a shelter house, playground, splash pad, fairy garden, and athletic fields, catering to families and sports enthusiasts. A crushed limestone path winds along Alum Creek, leading to a dog park, gazebo, and fire pit overlooking the creek. Whether strolling, picnicking, or exploring the community gardens, this park provides ample opportunities for recreation and reconnecting with nature.


Commonwealth Park

Commonwealth Park, nestled between North Parkview and North Drexel, is a versatile green space in Bexley. Approximately one-third of its area serves as athletic fields for youth sports programs, fostering an active lifestyle. The remaining portion is dedicated to passive recreation, featuring outdoor exercise stations on the western side, allowing residents to enjoy leisure activities amidst nature’s embrace. This dual-purpose park harmoniously blends athletic pursuits and tranquil relaxation within its boundaries.


Shopping


Couple Window Shopping

Bexley residents have a vibrant shopping and entertainment destination right at their doorstep: The Bexley Square Shopping District. This lively district features a diverse array of offerings, catering to various tastes and interests. From independent art galleries showcasing the works of local creators to well-stocked grocery stores, trendy boutiques, and cozy cinemas, there’s something for everyone.


A quick ten-minute drive north of Bexley is Easton Town Center, the Midwest’s premier shopping, dining, and entertainment destination. Located in Columbus, Ohio, this open-air complex attracts over 30 million visitors annually with its impressive lineup of 200+ best-in-class retailers and luxury brands. Easton Town Center offers a pedestrian-friendly environment with charming town squares, fountains, and parks, creating a delightful atmosphere for a day of shopping and leisure. Beyond its retail offerings, the center boasts some of Columbus’ most exciting dining options, catering to diverse culinary preferences. Additionally, it houses Ohio’s largest movie theater and a world-class comedy club, making it a one-stop hub for entertainment and leisure.


Dining


Dinner with Friends

Whether you’re planning a brunch get-together, celebrating a special occasion, or just out to grab a quick bite, there’s a wealth of exceptional dining destinations located in and around Bexley.


Some of the best restaurants in the area are:


Rubino’s Pizza
2643 E. Main Street, Bexley, Ohio


Rubino’s Pizzeria is a Bexley, Ohio institution that has been serving up its iconic crunchy thin-crust pizza in a no-nonsense, old-school atmosphere since 1954.


This beloved local staple offers a unique pizza experience that defies traditional categorization. The ultra-thin crust, resembling the crispness of a wheat-thin cracker, sets the stage for a distinctive pie. The sauce boasts a slightly bitter flavor, contrasting with the characteristic sweetness found in most Columbus-style pizzas. While the cheese is applied lightly, regulars know to order “extra cheese” for a more generous portion. However, the true star of the show is the sausage topping, cut into paper-thin rectangles unlike any other pizza topping.


Rubino’s modest interior, untouched since the 1970s, adds to the charm of this time-honored eatery, which has become a cherished part of Bexley’s culinary heritage and family traditions.


Barcelona
263 East Whittier Street, Columbus, Ohio


Barcelona is a culinary gem that seamlessly blends metropolitan chic with Old World European charm, offering a fusion of Spanish small plates and paella in the heart of Columbus’ German Village.


This award-winning restaurant boasts an impressive wine list, recognized annually by Wine Spectator for its extensive selection of California and Spanish wines. The bustling, sleek space with a greenery-filled patio creates a vibrant yet sophisticated ambiance, inviting diners to indulge in a delectable Spanish-inspired dining experience.


The Guild House
624 North High Street, Columbus, Ohio


The Guild House is an artisan eatery located in the vibrant Short North Arts District of Columbus, Ohio, where its “culinary guild” takes pride in showcasing creative American cuisine.


This establishment sources locally grown ingredients whenever possible, allowing the chefs to collaborate and craft seasonal offerings that are regionally and globally inspired, executed with artistic technique in an energetic and inviting space. The carefully curated wine list features diverse selections from around the world, complemented by the bar chefs’ skillfully crafted fresh-squeezed juices and spirits.


The Guild House embodies the essence of genuine hospitality, with a lot of love infused into every plate, inviting diners to experience a unique culinary collection from their esteemed guild of artisans.


Events


Father and Daughter

There’s always something to look forward to when you’re living in Bexley, thanks to a fantastic lineup of fun events and celebrations scheduled throughout the year.


Remember to mark your calendars for these exciting communitywide events:


  • Arbor Day. Celebrating the lush, verdant beauty of Bexley’s neighborhoods, parks, and hidden oases, the annual Arbor Day festivities invite the community to explore the city’s treasured Arboretum.

  • Community Campout. Come spring, Jeffrey Park hosts a fun-filled overnight adventure for families with a bonfire, games, activities, and delicious food.

  • Egg Dash. In April, thousands of prize-filled eggs are scattered across Jeffrey Lawn behind the Mansion to create a thrilling egg-hunting experience for kids.

  • Fourth of July in Bexley. Kicking off with the annual John Barr 5k and legendary parade, Bexley’s Independence Day celebrations continue with a community extravaganza on Main Street, featuring live music, exciting activities, and a mesmerizing fireworks display.

  • Harvest Festival. Head to Jeffrey Park for Bexley’s Harvest Festival, a free annual event featuring a corn maze, an enchanted walk, games, and more.

  • Tree Lighting. Drexel Circle will come alive with holiday cheer as performances by local school groups, hot chocolate, cookies, candy canes, and a visit from Santa Claus himself culminate in the lighting of the magnificent Christmas tree by the Mayor.

For more information on other events and celebrations in Bexley, head to this page.


FIND YOUR DREAM HOME IN BEXLEY, OHIO TODAY WITH CONLEY & PARTNERS


Find the best homes for sale in Bexley, Ohio today by getting in touch with our elite team of Realtors from Conley & Partners! With our wealth of experience, extensive market knowledge, and reputation for highly personalized service, you can look forward to a seamless and stress-free search.


Call us today at 614.595.4344 or send us an email. You can also leave us a message here. We’d love to hear from you!

AvailableProperties
Skip to content